Back in 2009, when I fell down a flight of stairs and injured myself, I had no concept of what chronic pain really meant.
I had been a nurse for about five years and had doled out my share of pain pills and muscle relaxers. Someone had pain, I gave them a pill and then reassessed about an hour later to see how effective it had been. If there wasn’t the expected level of relief, I called the attending MD to get an order for a different medication.
We were just starting to talk about non-pharmacologic interventions like visualization and breathing, but those interventions were often limited by the time available at the bedside. Mindfulness-based stress reduction tools were just starting to become mainstream.
This is what I understood about pain and injury at the time: something causes pain, like surgery or an injury, and as the body heals, the pain eventually goes away.
What I didn’t understand was what could happen when pain stayed.
Pain science has changed considerably in the years since then. In 2009, we weren’t talking about pain the way we do today. The role of the brain and nervous system in the pain experience wasn’t something I was taught in nursing school or something we routinely discussed in clinical practice.
So, when I was injured, I wasn’t thinking about how my nervous system was processing pain or whether my body felt safe. I was thinking about the places that hurt and wondering how to make them stop hurting.
And I think that’s still how many of us think about pain today, until the usual approaches don’t bring the relief we expected.
When pain stays, the search for answers can become almost as consuming as the pain itself. We look for the right doctor, the right test, the right treatment, or the person who can finally explain what’s wrong and offer a solution.
I understand that search because I’ve been there. It’s the reason I have the career I have today.
But current pain research is showing us that we may have been looking at persistent pain through too narrow of a lens. If we focus only on the part of the body that hurts, we may miss another important part of the pain experience: the brain and nervous system.
Widening the Lens
When I widen the lens and look back at what was happening in my life when I fell, I see things very differently than I did then.
I was under a tremendous amount of stress. There were challenges in my marriage, the ups and downs of parenting a teenager who was a bit off the rails, and a demanding job managing a building that was going through its own difficult season. On top of that, I was commuting an hour each way.
I was barely managing it. I was getting up, going to work, taking care of my family, and doing what needed to be done, but there wasn’t any room for recovery. As a Director of Nursing, I was on call 24/7/365.
Then I fell down the stairs and added a significant physical injury to everything my body was already navigating.
At the time, I saw those things as completely separate. Stress was stress. My injuries were my injuries. The pain was coming from the places I had hurt when I fell.
Today, I don’t see those pieces as separate.
This doesn’t mean stress caused my pain. And it certainly doesn’t mean the injuries weren’t real. It means my nervous system wasn’t experiencing that fall in isolation. It was responding to an injury while also navigating a life that was already carrying a significant load.
And that’s where the idea of “safety” starts to become important when we talk about how we experience pain.
What Does Safety Have to Do with Pain?
The word “safety” can sound a little strange in a conversation about pain. I know it would have sounded strange to me in 2009. I wasn’t in danger. Why would my nervous system need to feel safe?
But safety in this context isn’t simply about whether we are physically safe at this moment.
The International Association for the Study of Pain describes pain as a personal experience influenced by biological, psychological and social factors. It also makes an important distinction: pain and nociception, the nervous system’s process of detecting potentially harmful stimuli, are not the same thing.
Here’s an example from my own life.
My right knee almost always has a little bit. If I’ve walked a long distance and then sat for a while, like I might at a football game, it can be pretty stiff when I stand back up.
So, there I am sitting in the stands when I realize I have to pee, or the game is almost over, and I know we’ll be leaving soon. Before I’ve even stood up, I’m already thinking about my knee and those uneven stadium steps I’ll have to navigate. My thoughts:
“This is probably going to hurt.”
“ What if my knee gives out?”
“ What if I can’t get down those steps?”
“What if I fall and embarrass myself, or knock my teeth out?”
And just like that, before I’ve even taken a step, I’m already expecting something bad to happen. I’m afraid. My body tenses, and those thoughts can actually make the pain experience worse.
Instead, I can interrupt that cycle and give my brain some different information. “You’re okay.”
“You’ve got this.”
“There’s a rail right here.”
“Take your time.”
“You can stop and rest if you need to.”
The pain in my knee hasn’t magically disappeared. The uneven steps haven’t changed, but my experience of that moment can change.
Rather than continuing to feed my brain reasons to be afraid of the next step, I’m giving it information that says, “I can handle this.”
That is what I mean when I talk about creating evidence of safety.
It isn’t pretending something doesn’t hurt. It isn’t positive thinking your way out of pain. It’s recognizing that what we think, feel and anticipate can become part of the pain experience, too.
I wish I had understood this earlier in my journey. .
I spent a lot of time looking for someone or something that could make the pain go away.
What I didn’t know was that learning more about how pain works, paying attention to what increased fear and tension, and creating more opportunities for my nervous system to experience safety could also be part of the process.
I look at pain very differently today.
We need to pay attention to what hurts and seek appropriate care when something is wrong, but I also know there can be value in widening the lens.
Sometimes the next step isn’t another search for what’s wrong, it’s helping the nervous system experience something different.
Want to explore this a little further?
On Tuesday’s Less Stress in Life podcast, Lindsay and I are talking about the mind-body connection and the role it can play in the chronic pain experience. Watch for the new episode Tuesday, September 15.