This week, I noticed a theme in my office. Several women talked about changes they want to make, especially when it comes to putting their own needs somewhere on the list. They know something needs to shift. Yet as soon as they consider doing things differently, the old tapes start playing and try to keep us in the very patterns we want to change.
“I worry that I’m going to disappoint my family.”
“It feels wrong to pay attention to my own needs.”
“What if I’m being selfish?”
When a message has been with us for years, it can feel less like a thought and more like the truth.
I’ve been listening to The Pain Habit by Drew Coverdale and it has me thinking about pain as a protective response. Our brains draw on many kinds of information when deciding whether we need protection. That can include what is happening in the body, along with our emotions, past experiences, and beliefs.
It brought to mind moments when something someone said filled me with shame. I remember my heart hurting or feeling weak in the knees. I struggle with my knees today, and I find myself wondering whether there could be a connection.
I don’t know for sure whether those experiences contribute to my knee pain because there are many possible reasons for pain. But I’m curious about what we learn from difficult experiences and how those lessons might shape our responses later.
That question connects with what I’ve been hearing from women in my office. If putting everyone else first has felt like the safest way to avoid conflict or disappointment for years, choosing differently may feel uncomfortable at first, even when the change matters to you.
Charles Duhigg, author of The Power of Habit, describes habits as a pattern involving a cue, a routine, and a reward. Imagine someone asking you for help when you’re already exhausted. You say yes without pausing. For a moment, you feel relieved: you haven’t disappointed anyone or had an uncomfortable conversation.
That relief is real. So is the cost of saying yes when you needed to rest.
Why Change Takes Practice
After enough practice, the response can happen so quickly that you barely notice there was a choice. Then one day you decide, “My needs matter too.” The next request comes, though, and you say yes again.
It’s easy to feel discouraged. I know better. Why am I still doing this?
When a client says something like that, I often ask, “How old are you?”
They tell me, and I say, “You’ve had that many years to practice the old way. It’s going to take some time to practice the new habits you want.”
I’m not suggesting it will take that many years to change. I say it because we tend to expect so much of ourselves too quickly. We hear new information, decide to make a different choice, and wonder why the old response hasn’t disappeared by the end of the week.
Making Room for a New Response
Knowing something new and practicing something new are different things. Sometimes practice looks like noticing the old tape before you answer. Taking a breath. Saying, “Let me check what I have room for,” instead of giving an immediate yes.
Other times, you may recognize the pattern only afterward. You can still get curious about what prompted it and consider what you’d like to try next time.
The old tape may continue to play while you’re learning a new response. Its return doesn’t erase the practice you’ve done.
I think about my knees, and about the women I see who live with pain and tension in their necks, shoulders, and jaws. I wonder how often an old pattern feels safer to the brain simply because it’s familiar. Saying yes, pushing through, and keeping everyone else comfortable may be exhausting, but the brain knows what to expect.
A different choice can feel uncomfortable at first. That doesn’t mean it’s the wrong choice. Pausing before you answer, noticing the old message, and trying a new response gives your brain a chance to learn that doing things differently can be safe, too.
You’re not going to respond the way you want every time. The old pattern has years of practice behind it. Each time you pause and try something different, you give your brain another experience to learn from. Change takes repetition, and every small step matters.